The Cuban “Threat”

The Cuban “Threat”

Description image by Robert Huish Assistant Professor of international development studies, Dalhousie University.
  • First Posted: Jan 07 2010 09:26 AM
  • Updated: 5 months ago

If the U.S. wants to put Cuba on a terror list, they might as well add the Red Cross and Doctors Without Borders too.

Is it really 2010? It feels more like 1962. After the attempted Christmas Day bomb plot on a plane bound for Detroit from Amsterdam, the Obama Administration added Cubans and travelers from Cuba coming to the United States to the “special scrutiny” protocols reserved for “state sponsors of terrorism.”

What in the world for? Cuba poses zero threat to the United States. But still, Washington gets the jitters. Could it be paranoia left over from the Cold War? Russia pulled its nuclear arms out of Cuba in 1962 before pulling themselves out of Cuba altogether in 1991. Perhaps the Obama Administration hasn’t paid close attention to Cuban history. It might be hard to do when their focus is on maintaining its economic embargo.

Including Cuba on a list of state sponsors of terrorism is ridiculous. Cuba’s foreign relations are grounded on principles of solidarity, cooperation, and partnerships. This has unfolded through business deals, energy consortiums, medical internationalism, and education exchanges with many countries. Not once has Cuba condoned, let alone supported, violent terrorist attacks on the U.S. or any other nation. As The Washington Post’s Eugene Robinson put it, “It is not the Al-Cuba network.”

In fact, it is Cuba that has been a victim of terrorism.

In 1976, Luis Posada Carriles, a Cuban-born, Venezuelan, anti-Castro, former CIA operative, was found responsible for exploding Cubana flight 455, killing all 73 people on board. Cuban, Venezuelan and U.S. authorities all concluded that Posada was responsible. Posada remained in Venezuela until 2005 when he requested asylum to the United States, which he was granted. On May 17, 2005, Posada was detained by Homeland Security for extradition to Venezuela, but the move was overruled by an immigration judge who believed that Posada may face torture in Venezuela. He remains free in the U.S.

Then in 1997 Salvadorian Raul Ernesto Cruz exploded a bomb in Havana’s Copacabana hotel, killing Italian-Canadian Fabio di Celmo. Also in 1997, Alpha 66, a Miami-based Cuban exile terrorist group, claimed responsibility for further bombings in Havana at the hotels Nacional, Cohiba, and Capri as well as at the offices of Havanatour based in Nassau. Since 1990, Cuba claims that dozens of terrorist attacks have been attempted against its government.

Despite Cuba being a repeated victim of terrorism, the U.S. still sees the country as a threat. Why?

Due to “its relations with other state sponsors of terrorism” goes the official story from Washington. What do these relations look like? Does Cuba provide weapons to Somalia? No. Does Cuba provide training for Al-Qaeda? No. They do, however, send medical professionals to other countries like Pakistan that are on the list of “state sponsors of terrorism.”

On October 8, 2005, after a devastating earthquake in the Kashmir region killed 79,000 people, left over three million homeless, and impacted a total of eight million people, Cuba had a team of close to 2,000 medical professionals on the ground. Pakistan and Cuba had cool political relations at best before this tragedy. Those doctors, nurses, paramedics, and technicians set up field hospitals in remote parts of the country, treating over 1.1 million people in total.

The Cuban doctors offered not just emergency medicine, but also primary care to the poor, many of whom had never seen a doctor in their lives. Victims who required prosthetic limbs and advanced treatment were flown back to Cuba to receive care at no charge. The Cuban team left after 13 months, and when they did, they offered 1,000 medical scholarships to Pakistani youth so that the next time an earthquake hit, there would hopefully be more Pakistani doctors ready to help.

If this sort of humanitarian behaviour is sponsoring terror, then why not include members of the Red Cross? That humanitarian organization has been offering much needed medical care to the Sudanese, another country on the terror list. And the Red Cross has been long present in the Middle East, offering care to victims of war and violence even in Yemen! Surely this sort of assistance should place every single Red Cross volunteer on a special scrutiny list. And what about Médicins Sans Frontiérs? Forget the fact that they received the Nobel Peace Prize in 1999, they’ve been helping in the Sudan since 1979.

Of course suggesting that the Red Cross and MSF be placed on a scrutiny list is lunacy, and if the Obama Administration or any other administration tried it, the public outcry would be enormous. How could a government deem humanitarianism to be the sponsorship of terrorism? We would not tolerate it. Yet Cuba gets landed on the list for its long-standing effort to help others.

President Obama seems to want progressive relationships with Cuba, and Cubans very much want progressive relationships with the U.S., but the machinery of Homeland Security and the State Department is not helping the cause. Obama said at the 2009 Organization of American States meeting that he had heard much about Cuba’s medical internationalism and that it was a reminder to the U.S. that foreign policy can involve much more than military interventions. Hopefully the president remembers his remarks and removes Cuba from the state sponsor terrorist list. And hopefully in the process the technocrats at Homeland Security get a much-needed crash course in the history and politics of Cuba.

TAGS: Politics

Comments

Re:Marks

rules of engagement

Your statement: “Not once has Cuba condoned, let alone supported, violent terrorist attacks on the U.S. or any other nation” is contradicted by a lot of facts.But for the sake of space will touch on three instances. The New York Times reported on November 18, 1962 how the day before the FBI seized a cache of explosives and incendiary devices in a Manhattan loft, arresting three Cubans, among them Roberto Santiesteban Casanova an attaché of Cuba’s United Nations mission, whose application for diplomatic immunity had not yet been approved, Jose Garcia Orellana, 42 who operated the Manhattan jewelry manufacturing shop where the arsenal was seized, and a college student who worked part time at the shop and charged them with planning to place bombs in stores, oil refineries, and in the New York subway system. The State Department requested that two other Cuban diplomats, Jose Gomez Abad, 21 and his wife Elsa, 20, leave the country. According to the Associated Press story dated November 20, 1962 they had planned to unleash a reign of terror in metropolitan New York. For example the Harford Courant in a 1999 investigative reported on Cuba backing the Macheteros, a Puerto Rican terrorist group that robbed a Wells Fargo armored car in 1983 netting $7.1 million of which $2 million made its way via diplomatic pouch to the Cuban regime in exchange for financing the robbery and providing logistical support. The Courant also reported that in 1975 the Macheteros took credit for the Fraunces Tavern bombing in New York which killed 4 and wounded 63 people. The Cuban government has published the "Mini Manual for Revolutionaries" written by the late Brazilian urban terrorist Carlos Marighella and a friend of Fidel Castro, which gives precise instructions in terror tactics, kidnappings, has been translated into numerous languages and distributed worldwide by the Cuban dictatorship. The chapter on terrorism concludes: Terrorism is a weapon the revolutionary can never relinquish. An online copy of the above mentioned text is displayed on the website of Assata Shakur a fugitive from American justice who fled to Cuba in 1984 for the murder of a police officer and lives there today. There are many more examples with links here: http://cubanexilequarter.blogspot.com/2010/01/why-cubas-dictatorial-government-is-on.html

John Suarez

LATEST NEWS

So Long and Thanks for All The Hits

In which we bid adieu and do something t...

MacKay Underestimated Libya Cost by $300 M

Well, at least we won, kinda....

SpaceX Laying Groundwork for Visits to Private Space Stations

No more low-orbit fly-bys for SpaceX –...

Globe and Mail To Hide Behind Paywall

As if they actually expect people to pay...

MCA's Death Puts 7 Beastie Boys Albums on Billboard 200

Only Hello Nasty and To The Five Borough...

Prince Charles Does The Weather, Is Actually Charming

While he might never get to be king, at ...

Greek Unemployment Hits New High

One in four Greeks are unemployed, while...

NDP Outpolling Tories

The NDP is now nipping at the Tories' he...

Details of First Low-Cost 'Artificial Leaf' Published

An MIT chemist has found a way to replic...

National Post Infographic Details Child, Forced Labour Worldwide

Some of the world's hottest economies ...

Rothko, Pollock Help Smash Contemporary Art Auction Record

Nearly $400 million was spent on a haul ...

Only A Quarter of Americans Support Afghanistan War

A new poll shows that support for the de...

play

FEATURED VIDEO

The Spirit Bear has come to symbolize the mystery and greatness of the West Coast but also what is threatened by oil interests.

<i>Tipping Barrels</i> follows surfers into the Great Bear Rainforest, where they learn more about the region and issues confronting it.

Tipping Barrels Follows Surfers into Great Bear Rainforest

The Spirit Bear has come to symbolize the mystery and greatness of the West Coast but also what is threatened by oil interests. Tipping Barrels follows surfers into the Great Bear Rainforest, where they learn more about the region and issues confronting it.